10 SEO Audit Tools Compared for 2026: From RM0 to RM1,424 a Month, by What Each One Can See

Key takeaways
- Start with the two free tools from the search engines themselves. Google Search Console is the only tool that shows which of your pages Google actually indexed. Bing Webmaster Tools is the only free report of how often Copilot cites you.
- Best paid crawler for most sites: Screaming Frog SEO Spider at £199 a year (about RM1,083). The free version crawls 500 URLs and now renders JavaScript.
- Best all-in-one suites: Semrush, Ahrefs and SE Ranking. All three include a site audit, starting at US$129 to US$139.95 a month (about RM526 to RM571).
- Best for large or JavaScript-heavy sites: JetOctopus (crawls plus server logs, from US$349 a month) and Lumar (enterprise, sales-led pricing).
- The rule we use: apply the Three-Source Rule. An audit is complete only when it combines a crawl (what is on the site), index data (what Google kept) and logs (what bots actually fetched). No single tool on this list covers all three.
In this article
How We Ranked This List
We scored each tool on five things, in this order: what data it can see that others cannot, how many URLs it handles, its price in ringgit, how clearly it prioritises fixes, and its AI search coverage. A tool was left out if it only rescans the same public HTML as a better crawler on the list.
- Unique visibility. Does it show index data, log data, real-user speed data or AI citation data? Or does it only show what any crawler sees?
- Scale. URL limits per crawl or per month, and whether it renders JavaScript.
- Price in RM. List price at the exchange rates above, with any free tier noted.
- Prioritisation. Does it rank issues, or does it hand you 300 warnings with equal weight?
- AI search coverage. AI-bot tracking, AI citation reporting or AI-readiness checks.
Disclosure: Mackyclyde SEO uses SE Ranking and Semrush in day-to-day client work, and both are on this list. Neither vendor paid for placement, and this post contains no affiliate links.
The Comparison Table
Table 1: The 10 tools by type, entry price, crawl limit and the data each adds
| # | Tool | Type | Free tier | Entry paid price (approx. RM) | Crawl limit at entry | What it sees that a crawler alone doesn’t |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Google Search Console | Search engine console | Yes, full | Free | n/a (Google’s own data) | Google’s index status, queries, clicks |
| 2 | Screaming Frog SEO Spider | Desktop crawler | 500 URLs | £199/yr (RM1,083/yr) | Unlimited (your hardware) | Nothing beyond the crawl; best crawl per ringgit |
| 3 | Sitebulb | Desktop + cloud crawler | 14-day trial | US$13.50/mo Lite, annual (RM55) | 10,000 URLs per audit (Lite) | Prioritised “Hints” with explanations |
| 4 | Semrush Site Audit | All-in-one suite | 100 pages | US$139.95/mo (RM571) | 100,000 pages/month | Keyword, backlink and AI visibility data alongside the audit |
| 5 | Ahrefs Site Audit | All-in-one suite | Ahrefs Free (own sites) | US$129/mo Lite (RM526) | 25,000 pages per project | Backlink index in the same tool |
| 6 | SE Ranking Website Audit | All-in-one suite | 14-day trial | US$129/mo Core (RM526) | 250,000 pages/month | Rank tracking plus AI visibility (25 prompts, 5 engines) |
| 7 | JetOctopus | Cloud crawler + log analyser | 7-day trial | US$349/mo Growth, annual (RM1,424) | 500,000 URLs/month | Server logs, including AI bots |
| 8 | Lumar | Enterprise platform | No | Sales-led, no public price | Enterprise scale | Regression testing before releases go live |
| 9 | Bing Webmaster Tools | Search engine console | Yes, full | Free | n/a | Copilot and Bing AI citation counts |
| 10 | PageSpeed Insights | Speed tester | Yes, full | Free | One URL at a time | Real-user (field) speed data from Chrome |
Why Does No Single Tool Give You a Complete Audit?
A crawler can only see what your server sends it. It cannot see which pages Google decided to keep in its index, and it cannot see which URLs Googlebot or AI bots actually request. That takes three different data sources, which is the Three-Source Rule: crawl, index and logs.
Google does not index everything it crawls. Its index has tiers. Pages with weak internal links, duplicated content or low perceived quality get stored in lower tiers or dropped. Search Console’s “Crawled, currently not indexed” status is what that looks like from your side. A crawler can report a page as healthy (200 status, unique title, indexable) while Google has quietly left it out. Only Search Console shows that gap.
Logs fill in the third view. A crawl shows the links that exist. Logs show what bots actually did: which sections Googlebot visits daily, which it has not touched in months, and how often GPTBot or ClaudeBot request your pages. On a 500-page site you can usually skip logs. On a 50,000-URL e-commerce catalogue with faceted filters, logs are often where crawl waste shows up.
Table 2: What each data source can and cannot see
| Question | Crawler (Screaming Frog, Sitebulb) | Index data (Search Console, Bing WMT) | Logs (JetOctopus, server files) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Is the page technically indexable? | Yes | Yes | No |
| Did Google actually index it? | No | Yes | No |
| How often does Googlebot fetch it? | No | Partial (crawl stats) | Yes |
| Do AI bots request it? | No | No (Bing shows Copilot citations, not fetches) | Yes |
| Which queries does it earn clicks for? | No | Yes | No |
1. Google Search Console
Capabilities: Page indexing report, URL Inspection with live test, Core Web Vitals (field data), sitemaps, manual actions, Performance report (queries, clicks, impressions).
Search Console is first because it is Google’s own record. Every other tool on this list estimates or simulates what Google sees. URL Inspection’s live test shows the HTML Google rendered. On a JavaScript site, that is the fastest way to catch content that only exists after scripts run. We traced a Malaysian hotel group’s near-total loss of indexed content to exactly this kind of rendering fault. The full case is in our guide to what an SEO audit checks.
Limit: it reports problems but does not crawl your site on demand, and the Performance report keeps 16 months of data. Price: free.
2. Screaming Frog SEO Spider
Capabilities: Desktop crawl, JavaScript rendering, custom extraction, redirect and canonical audits, GA4/Search Console/PageSpeed API connections, “Crawl with OpenAI & Gemini” for running AI prompts over crawled pages.
This is the reference crawler, and £199 a year (about RM1,083) makes it the cheapest unlimited-crawl licence here. The free version crawls 500 URLs and, per the vendor’s current pricing page, includes JavaScript rendering. That alone covers most Malaysian SME sites. The OpenAI and Gemini connection lets you run a prompt over every crawled page, for example “classify this page’s search intent”. You supply your own API key.
Limit: it runs on your computer, so a 1-million-URL crawl needs a strong machine and database storage mode. There are no collaboration features. Price: free to 500 URLs, then £199 per licence per year (£169 each at 20+ licences).
3. Sitebulb
Capabilities: Desktop and cloud crawling, 300+ prioritised “Hints” with explanations, crawl comparison, accessibility and front-end checks, MCP access for connecting audit data to AI assistants.
Sitebulb’s strength is explanation. Each issue comes with a priority and a plain-language reason, which matters when you hand a report to a client or a developer who has never heard of canonical tags. Lite caps audits at 10,000 URLs. Pro goes to 500,000 URLs, or 2 million if your machine can cope. Sitebulb Cloud starts at £95 a month (about RM517) with a two-user minimum.
Limit: the Lite cap rules it out for most e-commerce catalogues. Price: Lite from about US$13.50 a month billed annually, Pro about US$35 a month, Cloud from £95 a month. 14-day trial, no card.
4. Semrush Site Audit
Capabilities: 140+ technical checks, scheduled crawls, JavaScript rendering on higher tiers, AI-ready site audit (Semrush One plans), keyword, backlink and AI visibility tracking in one account.
Semrush restructured its plans in July 2026. The old Pro plan became “SEO” at US$139.95 a month (about RM571) with 100,000 audit pages a month. The new Semrush One tiers (Starter US$199, Pro+ US$299, Advanced US$549) add AI visibility tracking and an “AI-ready” site audit. That audit flags issues that may stop AI assistants from understanding a page. We use Semrush alongside SE Ranking. Its audit is most useful when the same account also holds your rank tracking, so a fix can be checked against movement on the queries it was meant to help.
Limit: check the 100-page free audit limit and per-month page caps before scheduling weekly crawls of a large site. Price: SEO from US$139.95 a month. 7-day trial.
5. Ahrefs Site Audit
Capabilities: Cloud crawl, 170+ checks, internal link opportunities, JavaScript rendering, the Ahrefs backlink index in the same account. Ahrefs Free (formerly Webmaster Tools) gives limited Site Audit and Site Explorer access for sites you verify.
Ahrefs Free is the strongest no-cost cloud audit for your own site. Once you verify ownership, you get a scheduled crawl and a health score without paying. The paid Lite plan (US$129 a month, about RM526) gives 100,000 crawl credits a month and caps projects at 25,000 pages. That is enough for a typical service business but tight for a store with thousands of product variants.
Limit: no free trial of paid plans, and Ahrefs states it never discounts. Price: Free for verified sites, Starter US$29, Lite US$129 a month.
6. SE Ranking Website Audit
Capabilities: 120+ checks grouped as errors, warnings and notices; page-level fix guidance; Core Web Vitals; scheduled audits; rank tracking; AI visibility tracking across 5 AI engines.
SE Ranking renamed its plans in 2026. Core costs US$129 a month or US$103.20 billed annually (about RM421), and it includes 250,000 audit pages a month. That is the highest audit allowance per ringgit among the three suites. Its AI visibility module tracks 25 prompts daily across 5 AI engines at the Core tier. An add-on from US$71.20 a month covers AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, ChatGPT and Copilot with 200 prompts. We use it for client rank tracking and audits.
Limit: its backlink index is smaller than Ahrefs’ or Semrush’s, so link audits may miss referring domains. Price: Core from US$103.20 a month annually. 14-day trial, no card.
Not sure which findings matter? Send us your URL and within 2 business days we’ll return your top indexing issues from Google’s own data, plus the three fixes we would make first. Get your free SEO audit →
7. JetOctopus
Capabilities: Cloud crawler (JavaScript rendering), log analyser covering Googlebot, Bingbot and AI bots, Search Console and GA4 joins, AI bot alerts, AI search visibility module, MCP integration. No per-seat or per-project fees.
JetOctopus is the tool for the third source in the Three-Source Rule. Its Growth plan (US$349 a month billed annually, about RM1,424) includes 500,000 crawled URLs and 2 million log lines a month. It lines up what your site links to against what Googlebot and AI crawlers actually requested. For a large marketplace, that is where you find whole sections bots have stopped visiting. Log review of this kind is a standard part of technical SEO work on large catalogue sites.
Limit: you need access to server or CDN logs. On shared hosting common among Malaysian SMEs, you often won’t have it. Price: Growth US$349, Pro US$809, Ultra US$1,559 a month (annual). 7-day trial capped at 10,000 URLs.
8. Lumar
Capabilities: Enterprise crawler (up to about 450 URLs per second), Monitor and Protect modules for regression testing in release pipelines, accessibility audits, GEO/AI search metrics, Jira and BI integrations.
Lumar (formerly Deepcrawl) fits organisations where a site release can break SEO overnight and several teams share responsibility. Its Protect module tests builds for SEO regressions before they go live. That is a different job from auditing what is already published.
Limit: pricing is sales-led with no public tiers, and reviewers report a steep learning curve. Price: quote only.
9. Bing Webmaster Tools
Capabilities: Site Scan (crawl audit up to your verified site), URL Inspection, IndexNow, Search Performance, and the AI Performance dashboard showing citations in Copilot and Bing AI answers.
Bing Webmaster Tools launched its AI Performance report in public preview on 10 February 2026. It added query-to-page mapping in March and four more reports (Intents, Topics, Citation Share and Compare) on 16 June 2026. It is the only free, first-party count of how often an AI answer engine cites your pages. It covers Microsoft’s ecosystem only, not ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google’s AI Overviews.
Limit: Bing’s share of Malaysian search is small, so treat its AI data as a sample, not the market. Price: free.
10. PageSpeed Insights
Capabilities: Chrome UX Report (CrUX) field data for the URL and origin, Lighthouse lab test, Core Web Vitals pass/fail.
Most crawlers report lab speed: one simulated load from a data centre. Google’s page experience signals use field data, which is real Chrome users’ load times over the previous 28 days. PageSpeed Insights shows both, so you can see whether a slow lab score affects real visitors on Malaysian mobile networks. Treat speed as a tiebreaker between pages that are otherwise close, not a primary ranking lever.
Limit: one URL at a time, and low-traffic pages have no field data. Price: free.
Which SEO Audit Tool Stack Fits Your Budget?
Quick Answer: For most Malaysian SMEs, the RM0 stack (Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools, PageSpeed Insights and Screaming Frog’s 500-URL free version) covers all three sources except logs. Add a paid crawler at about RM90 a month when the site passes 500 URLs. Move to a suite at RM420 to RM570 a month only when you also need rank and backlink data.
Table 3: Three budget stacks and what each one misses
| Budget | Stack | Covers | Misses |
|---|---|---|---|
| RM0 | Search Console + Bing Webmaster Tools + PageSpeed Insights + Screaming Frog free | Crawl (to 500 URLs), index, field speed, Copilot citations | Logs, competitor and backlink data |
| About RM90/month | The RM0 stack + Screaming Frog licence (RM1,083/yr) | Unlimited crawl with JS rendering | Logs, rank tracking, backlinks |
| RM420 to RM570/month | RM0 stack + SE Ranking Core, Ahrefs Lite or Semrush SEO | Scheduled audits, ranks, backlinks, AI visibility prompts | Logs; crawl caps on large sites |
How to Pick the Right SEO Audit Tool
- Ask what the tool sees that your free tools don’t. If the answer is “the same HTML Screaming Frog sees”, you are paying for the interface.
- Check the crawl cap against your real URL count. Count parameter URLs too. A 2,000-product store with colour and size filters can expose 30,000 crawlable URLs.
- Test JavaScript rendering on your own site. Compare the raw HTML word count with the rendered count on one key template.
- Check how issues are prioritised. A tool that weights a missing alt attribute the same as a missing sitemap creates the Health Score Trap: a high score on a site with real indexing problems.
- Confirm where the data goes. For sites handling personal data under the PDPA, check whether a cloud crawler stores page content on overseas servers, and for how long.
Red flag: an “AI SEO audit” tool that cannot tell you whether your pages are indexed. Google’s own guidance says a page must be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet before it can appear as a link in AI Overviews or AI Mode. An AI audit that skips indexing has skipped the first requirement.
There is also a structural point about link and content counts. When Google renders a page it separates header, sidebar, main content and footer, and it gives main-content text and links more weight. Links are also weighted by how likely someone is to click them. Most crawlers count a footer link the same as a link in a paragraph. Read “internal links: 340” as an upper bound, and check where your priority pages are linked from inside the body copy.
Get an Audit That Uses All Three Sources
Tools find issues. The hard part is deciding which three to fix first. Mackyclyde SEO runs full audits across 47 checkpoints in 6 categories. We combine crawl data, Google’s own index data and, where we can get access, server logs. We have done this for Malaysian sites in Kuala Lumpur, Selangor and Penang, in English and Bahasa Malaysia. See our SEO audit services in Malaysia, or check typical costs in our SEO pricing guide for Malaysia. If AI answers are the gap, start with our AI SEO service.
Free snapshot, 2 business days. We’ll check Google’s index coverage for your site, score your AI search readiness and send a ranked list of the first three fixes. Request your free audit →
Frequently Asked Questions About SEO Audit Tools
What is the best free SEO audit tool? Google Search Console is the best free tool, because it is the only one showing which pages Google actually indexed. Pair it with Screaming Frog’s free version (500 URLs, JavaScript rendering included) for the crawl, Ahrefs Free for scheduled cloud audits of a verified site, and Bing Webmaster Tools for Copilot citation data. Together they cost RM0.
Is Screaming Frog better than Semrush for site audits? For crawl depth and flexibility, yes. Screaming Frog has no URL cap on its £199 licence and lets you extract custom data. Semrush is better when you want scheduled audits, rank tracking and backlink data in one account, at about RM571 a month versus about RM90. Many agencies run both: Screaming Frog for deep dives, a suite for ongoing monitoring.
How often should I run an SEO audit tool on my site? Run a scheduled crawl weekly or monthly for sites that publish often, and a full crawl within 2 weeks of any redesign, migration or platform change. Check Search Console’s Page indexing report monthly. A sudden rise in “Crawled, currently not indexed” pages usually shows up there before it shows up in traffic.
Can an AI tool like ChatGPT replace an SEO audit tool? No. ChatGPT and similar assistants cannot crawl your full site, read your Search Console index data or access your server logs. They are useful on top of a crawler. Screaming Frog, Sitebulb and JetOctopus now pass crawl data to AI models through API keys or MCP, so the AI analyses real data rather than guessing.
Do SEO audit tools check for AI search visibility? Some do, in two different ways. Semrush’s AI-ready site audit and Lumar’s GEO metrics check whether pages are technically readable by AI systems. Bing Webmaster Tools, SE Ranking and Semrush One report actual citations or mentions in AI answers. The first is a readiness check. The second measures outcomes.
How much do SEO audit tools cost in Malaysia? At October 2026 exchange rates, expect RM0 for the search engine consoles, about RM90 a month (RM1,083 a year) for Screaming Frog, RM420 to RM570 a month for SE Ranking, Ahrefs or Semrush entry plans, and RM1,400+ a month for log-based platforms like JetOctopus. Most vendors bill in USD or GBP, so card FX fees apply.
